Dental Malpractice, Injuries, Informed Consent

Posted by Richard P. Hastings | May 13, 2011 | 0 Comments

Dentist, Injuries, Negligence and Informed Consent: Connecticut Supreme Court

David Shortell

v.

Normam Cavanagh et al

Argued: January 11, 20011

Decided: March 15, 2011

Facts: The Plaintiff, David Shortell, had an oral procedure performed by the defendant, Norman Cavanagh, a dentist, in December 2006 which he later sustained serious injuries from after the dentist's failure to obtain the patient's informed consent for the procedure. The plaintiff filed a complaint alleging the defendant committed negligence when failing to inform him of the significant risks involving the implant procedure and they were "significant enough that a reasonable person in the plaintiff's position would have withheld consent to the procedure." Since the plaintiff did not attached to the complaint either a good faith certificate or the written opinion of a similar health care provider, the defendant filed a motion to dismiss the complaint due to the plaintiff's failure to attached documents mandated by [§ 52-190a].'' The plaintiff objected to the dismissal because ''failure to obtain informed consent cause of action does not require a written opinion from a similar health care provider to be attached to the complaint and it does not require a certificate of good faith.'' The trial court granted the motion to dismiss on the ground that ''[g]iving the information about risk is a necessary part of the appropriate operating procedure and . . . failure to give it and proceeding to operate constitutes malpractice.'' The plaintiff again filed this appeal.

Issue:  Is § 52-190a relevant to the plaintiff's case of lack of informed consent?

Decision: The trial jury judgment is reversed and the case is remanded for further proceedings.

Reasons: The court had agreed with the plaintiff that General Statute Section 52-190a does not apply to the appeal filed.

Basing their judgment on precedent of Dias v. Grady, supra, 292 Conn. 359, ''we conclud[ed] that the phrase medical negligence, as used in § 52-190a (a), means breach of the standard of care and was not intended to encompass all of the elements of a cause of action for negligence.'' (Internal quotation marks omitted.) Thus, if an expert is needed to establish the standard of care, a fortiori, an opinion letter is required from a similar health care provider. It is likewise both consistent and logical to hold that if an expert is not required to establish the medical standard of care, an opinion letter is not required under § 52-190a. This is especially true in an action for lack of informed consent where our case law is so well established that the lay standard of materiality of risk is applicable."

Dissenting opinion: None

About the Author

Richard P. Hastings

Attorney Hastings concentrates his practice on personal injury and litigation. Devoted to helping those who have suffered some type of wrong, Richard P. Hastings concentrates his law practice on personal injury law.

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Sample

Aenean lacinia bibendum nulla sed consectetur. Donec sed odio dui. Maecenas sed diam eget risus varius blandit sit amet non magna. Nulla vitae elit libero, a pharetra augue. Curabitur blandit tempus porttitor. Morbi leo risus, porta ac consectetur ac, vestibulum at eros. Cras justo odio, dapibus ac facilisis in, egestas.

Let Us Fight for You

Local Presence. Statewide Coverage.

When you choose Hastings, Cohan & Walsh, LLP you will receive the one-on-one attention and individualized support that you deserve. Our Connecticut personal injury attorneys will not treat you as just another case number nor will we hand your case off to a paralegal.

Unlike other law firms, we will personally handle each legal aspect of your case, walking with you every step of the way. We aim to provide the highest quality representation possible. We have extensive experience and training in a variety of aspects of personal injury law. We obtain the knowledge and skill-set necessary to maximize your compensation.

440 Main Street
Suite 2

Ridgefield, CT 06877
203-438-7450
Mon, Tue, Wed, Thu, Fri: 08:30am - 05:00pm

Menu